As of May 18, 2026, the median asking price for new freehold homes in Tay is $279,900.
Compared with the other cities and townships in Simcoe:
Higher-priced than Tay: Oro-Medonte ($1,519,950, about 443% higher), Bradford West Gwillimbury ($1,494,495, about 433.9% higher), Adjala-Tosorontio ($1,449,450, about 417.8% higher), Essa ($1,224,990, about 337.7% higher), Tiny ($1,199,500, about 328.5% higher), Springwater ($996,995, about 256.2% higher), Penetanguishene ($964,000, about 244.4% higher), New Tecumseth ($908,700, about 224.7% higher), Wasaga Beach ($849,990, about 203.7% higher), Innisfil ($848,000, about 203% higher), Orillia ($826,900, about 195.4% higher), Collingwood ($808,950, about 189% higher), Severn ($796,400, about 184.5% higher), Clearview ($769,912, about 175.1% higher), Ramara ($758,944, about 171.1% higher), Midland ($749,900, about 167.9% higher), and Barrie ($734,900, about 162.6% higher).