As of July 3, 2026, the median asking price for 4-bedroom homes in Tay is $1,399,900.
Compared with the other cities and townships in Simcoe:
Higher-priced than Tay: Adjala-Tosorontio ($1,550,000, about 10.7% higher) and Oro-Medonte ($1,525,000, about 8.9% higher).
Lower-priced than Tay: Severn ($1,296,500, about 7.4% lower), Bradford West Gwillimbury ($1,250,000, about 10.7% lower), Clearview ($1,192,944, about 14.8% lower), Collingwood ($1,188,800, about 15.1% lower), Tiny ($1,184,500, about 15.4% lower), Springwater ($1,150,000, about 17.9% lower), Ramara ($1,100,000, about 21.4% lower), Innisfil ($1,099,999, about 21.4% lower), New Tecumseth ($1,044,500, about 25.4% lower), Penetanguishene ($929,000, about 33.6% lower), Essa ($906,185, about 35.3% lower), Barrie ($899,000, about 35.8% lower), Wasaga Beach ($849,990, about 39.3% lower), Orillia ($838,000, about 40.1% lower), and Midland ($774,900, about 44.6% lower).