58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON

Tay, Port McNicoll Hood
Methodist Island
3 Br | 2 Bath | 1100-1500 Sqft
$899,900 For Sale

Property Overview

  • Detached — Bungalow
  • SqFt: | 1100-1500 Sqft
  • Lot Size: 77.10 x 220.00 Feet
  • Age: n/a
  • Basement: None
  • Exterior: Board & Batten
  • Taxes: 3,669 / 2025
  • Zoning: n/a
  • MLS #: S12910002
  • Sewer: Septic
  • Heat Source: Electric , Baseboard

Property Description

A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes.

A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your experience begins on the included 21 foot bowrider. Arrive to the island after enjoying spectacular views and waving to your neighbors as you cruise by.

The 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage has been completely gutted and transformed into a turnkey high end property. New flooring, new kitchen, new appliances, new furniture, new bathrooms and pot lights throughout. With the bonus of a Muskoka room for extra sleeping quarters or peaceful retreat.

This cottage can sleep up to 10 people comfortably. The hot tub extends your days outdoors into the evenings with sounds of laughter and joy from the kids. Inside turn on Netflix and watch movies on the 75 big screen.

High speed internet when working remotely is top notch. This is more than a cottage, its a lifestyle!

Fridge, cooktop, wall oven, washer, dryer, hot tub, dock, freezer, furniture, BBQ

Property Details

  • For: For Sale
  • Type: Detached
  • Style: Bungalow
  • Lot: 77.10 x 220.00 Feet
  • Region: Simcoe
  • Hood: Port McNicoll
  • Zoning: n/a
  • Lot Irreg: Fronting on: East
  • Fronting On: East

Building Details

  • Age: n/a
  • Exterior: Board & Batten
  • Heat: Electric , Baseboard
  • A/C: None
  • Interior Features: Carpet Free, Water Heater Owned
  • Pool: None
  • Sewer: Septic
  • Garage: None
  • Total Parking: 0.00

Property Interior

  • Sqft: 1100-1500 Sqft
  • Bed: 3
  • Bath: 2
  • Kitchen: 1
  • Family Room: No
  • Basement: None
Rooms Details

Kitchen

Main Level

5.2 x 9.34

Living Room

Main Level

5.2 x 5.03

Bedroom

Main Level

4.47 x 4.06

Bedroom 2

Main Level

3.15 x 2.94

Bedroom 3

Main Level

3.15 x 4.32

Sunroom

Main Level

3.33 x 2.77

Bathroom

Main Level

3.15 x 1.24

4 Pc Bath

Bathroom

Main Level

2.1 x 1.14

3 Pc Ensuite

Property Listed by: CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
Virtual Tour: https://youtu.be/d1-C8KV8NOI

Home Valuation Estimate

What is 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON worth in today’s Port McNicoll, Tay market?

This HomeZira valuation preview helps buyers and sellers think through the asking price for this 3-bedroom Detached with 1100-1500 sq. ft. in Port McNicoll, Tay. The full estimate reviews the property’s location, home type, bedroom count, size range, age, and nearby comparable market activity after sign-in.

Property-specific estimate See a valuation range built around this listing’s local profile.
Comparable market context Review how similar nearby homes help frame value.
Buyer and seller guidance Use the estimate as a starting point before an offer or pricing decision.
Sign in to view the full valuation estimate.
Log in to view valuation Create free account

Similar Recently Sold Properties

Compare 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON with nearby homes that recently sold in the same market area.

Similar sold property preview
Sold recently

Sold price locked

List price available after sign-in

Similar sold home nearby

Hood, city and sold details available after sign-in
  • Beds
  • Baths
  • SqFt.
Type: Similar property type
DOM: Available after sign-in
Similar sold property preview
Sold recently

Sold price locked

List price available after sign-in

Similar sold home nearby

Hood, city and sold details available after sign-in
  • Beds
  • Baths
  • SqFt.
Type: Similar property type
DOM: Available after sign-in
Similar sold property preview
Sold recently

Sold price locked

List price available after sign-in

Similar sold home nearby

Hood, city and sold details available after sign-in
  • Beds
  • Baths
  • SqFt.
Type: Similar property type
DOM: Available after sign-in

Sign in to view recent similar sold properties

View recently sold comparable homes, including sold prices, list prices, sale dates, and property details.

Log in Register

Location

  • Address: 58 Methodist Island
  • Neighborhood: Port McNicoll
  • Zip/Postal Code: L0K 1R0
  • Nearby Amenities:
Map preview placeholder for 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON, Canada
Loads interactive map with Street View + zoom.

Mortgage Calculator

Mortgage Amount:$0
Monthly Mortgage (est.):$0
Payment (per period): $0
Estimated Monthly Total*$0
*Monthly total = monthlyized mortgage payment + taxes/12 + condo fee.

About 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0, Tay

Located at 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON in Tay (Port McNicoll neighbourhood), near Methodist Island. This freehold home offers Detached, ["Bungalow"], 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and 1100-1500 sq.ft. (approx.) in a layout suited to everyday family living. Basement: None • Garage: None • Heating: Electric Baseboard • Cooling: None. Property taxes are approximately $3,669 for 2025. A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes. A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your experience begins on the included 21 foot bowrider. Arrive to the island after enjoying spectacular views and waving to your neighbors as you cruise by. The 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage has been completely gutted and transformed into a turnkey high end property. New flooring, new kitchen, new appliances, new furniture, new bathrooms and pot lights throughout. With the bonus of a Mus.

FAQs for 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON , Port McNicoll , Tay

What are the listing details for 58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON?
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON is a Detached for sale in Tay, in the Port McNicoll neighbourhood, Simcoe. The current list price is $899,900. MLS number: S12910002.
How many bedrooms and bathrooms does this home have?
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON is listed as a Detached with a ["Bungalow"] style, featuring 3 bedroom(s) and 2 bathroom(s). The listed interior size range is 1100-1500 sq. ft..
What lot, basement, garage, or parking details are listed?
The lot size is listed as approximately 77.10 x 220.00 Feet. The basement is listed as: None. Garage type: None. Total parking: 0 space(s).
What heating, cooling, and exterior details are shown?
Heating is listed as: Electric, Baseboard. Cooling is listed as: None. Exterior/construction materials are listed as: Board & Batten .
Where is this property located?
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON is located in the Port McNicoll neighbourhood of Tay. The listed cross street is Methodist Island.
What information is available on this public listing page?
The public listing page shows current active listing information, property photos, room details when available, map location, listed price, property features, and contact options. Annual taxes are listed as $3,669 / 2025. Valuation tools and similar sold-property previews are available after sign-in where applicable, without displaying sold data in this public FAQ.

FAQ content is based on current active listing fields shown on this page. Sold prices, sold comparables, and VOW-only details are not included in this public FAQ.